The search for Love Island’s next leading lady is officially on, and it looks like viewers already have a few favourites in mind!

Following Maya Jama’s announcement that she would be stepping down as host of the popular ITV dating show after three years and nine series, speculation has been rife over who could be next to make those iconic slow-motion entrances into the villa.

According to reports, former Islanders Indiyah Polack, Chloe Burrows and Olivia Attwood, alongside social media personality and podcast host GK Barry, are among the names being considered to take over the coveted role.

While no official replacement has been confirmed, the rumoured line-up has already sparked quite the conversation online, with viewers divided over who deserves the opportunity.

One name receiving plenty of support is Indiyah Polack, who has built an impressive career since appearing on the show’s eighth series in 2022. From securing major brand partnerships, including PrettyLittleThing, to presenting at the MOBO Awards and becoming a familiar face on Love Island: Aftersun, the former Islander has established herself as a personality well beyond the villa.

For many, her career progression and continued involvement with the franchise make her a natural contender for the position.

However, Indiyah isn’t the only former Islander viewers are rooting for. Some have thrown their support behind Olivia Attwood, whose television career has flourished since her 2017 appearance, while others believe Chloe Burrows’ bubbly personality and presenting experience could bring a refreshing energy to the show.

Meanwhile, GK Barry’s inclusion has also caught viewers’ attention, with the internet personality having carved out a successful career in podcasting and television.

Despite the four rumoured contenders, some viewers have been calling for another familiar face to enter the conversation: Maura Higgins. The former Islander has become a popular choice among fans, particularly following her growing success as a television presenter.

‍

Interestingly, not everyone believes the role needs to go to just one person. Some viewers have suggested switching things up entirely by introducing a presenting duo, with one Resident commenting:

“Chloe and Indiyah as a duo would definitely get me watching love island again”

Another backed Olivia for the position, writing:

“I see Olivia for this one”

While opinions remain split, there’s also been plenty of love for all four women, with viewers recognising the different personalities and presenting styles each could bring to the franchise.

Of course, whoever takes over will have some pretty big shoes to fill. Maya’s three-year run saw her become a fan favourite, with her fashion moments, charisma and memorable villa entrances becoming just as much a talking point as the Islanders themselves.

With a new chapter approaching for the dating show, the question remains whether ITV will opt for a familiar former Islander, an established television personality or an entirely unexpected choice.

Residents, who would you like to see take over from Maya Jama? And would you be here for a hosting duo?

‍