.png)
.png)
Dancehall artist Spice, also known as Grace Hamilton, took to social media with a six-minute video addressing Shenseea's recent comments suggesting that her achievements and current statistics put her in a position to take the "Queen of Dancehall" title.
The exchange has sparked conversation among dancehall fans, with the two artists now at the centre of a debate about legacy, commercial success and cultural influence.
The disagreement began after Shenseea sparked conversation during an interview at a private event in Pembroke Pines, Florida, celebrating the release of her latest EP, Catalyst.
When asked about Spice's position in dancehall and whether she considered herself the genre's new queen, Shenseea acknowledged the veteran entertainer's achievements but suggested that her own success and statistics put her in contention for the title. She said:
“I respect Spice a lot. I mean, I respect all the people who were before me, who are performing in the business,”
However, she went on to add that, based on her current statistics and achievements, she believed she was the new Queen of Dancehall.
Her comments quickly divided dancehall fans, with some backing Shenseea's international success while others argued that Spice's influence, catalogue and contribution to the genre should not be overlooked.

In Spice's response, she suggested that she had deliberately held back from reacting because she believed the comments were an attempt to generate publicity around Shenseea's latest project and its first-week performance. She also made a claim about the number of downloads Catalyst received during its opening week, although the figure she mentioned has not been independently verified.
Among the questions Spice raised was how many solo dancehall records Shenseea had released without collaborations, questioning whether her achievements could be measured through statistics alone.
She also challenged the singer over her experience performing live without relying on backing recordings, as well as her participation in dancehall clashes, which Spice believes are an important part of the genre's culture. Spice further questioned Shenseea's cultural influence, pointing to the impact previous dancehall stars have had on fashion, language and Jamaican culture.
The veteran entertainer made it clear that she believes being the Queen of Dancehall requires more than streaming figures and international recognition, arguing that an artiste's cultural contribution and ability to connect with the streets should also be considered.
Spice also named Jada Kingdom and Shaneil Muir as artists she believes are more deserving of consideration for the title, challenging Shenseea to prove herself against either of them before claiming the crown.
The back-and-forth has once again opened up the debate about whether the title should be determined by commercial success, longevity, cultural influence or an artiste's overall contribution to dancehall.
One user said:
"SPICE IS THE QUEEN & SHENSEEA IS THE PRINCESS DEBATE IS OVER."
While another commented:
"She’s not wrong and if Shensea wants to prove her wrong then clash her!"
The latest exchange is not the first time Spice and Shenseea have found themselves at odds. The pair have had a complicated relationship over the years, with tensions reportedly dating back to 2021.
Their issues first became public after Spice shared a post praising Jada Kingdom for recognising her as the Queen of Dancehall and acknowledging her influence. Spice also appeared to take issue with the lack of recognition she received from other female artists who had come after her.
Shortly afterwards, fans noticed that Shenseea had unfollowed Spice on Instagram, sparking speculation about a fallout between the two. Spice later unfollowed Shenseea in return. At the time, Shenseea's supporters pointed to previous posts in which she had praised Spice, including one where she credited the veteran deejay with teaching her how to approach a beat.

Their rocky relationship also played out on reality television when the pair appeared together as judges on Zeus Network's Baddies Caribbean Auditions in 2024, alongside American reality star Natalie Nunn.
During one behind-the-scenes moment, the two dancehall stars found themselves discussing the breakdown of their relationship, with both offering different explanations for why they had stopped following each other on Instagram.
Spice questioned Shenseea about allegedly unfollowing her, reminding the singer that she had shown her love and support from the beginning of her career. She also brought up their first meeting in the recording studio, asking Shenseea whether she remembered the advice she had given her about approaching a beat. However, Shenseea disputed Spice's version of events, claiming that Spice had actually blocked her first, which automatically caused her to unfollow the veteran artist.
The exchange, which appeared to be partly playful, quickly attracted attention online, with fans debating who was responsible for the fallout. Interestingly, despite their differences, the two were able to share judging duties during the auditions, showing that they could at least be in the same room professionally.
With Spice now publicly challenging Shenseea to defend her position and giving her 24 hours to respond to her questions, fans will undoubtedly be watching to see whether the singer chooses to address the challenge.