.png)
.png)
The American singer Willow Smith, 26, appeared on the show on Tuesday, November 17, where she performed a selection of tracks, including her songs ‘Circles’ and ‘Unconditional’, before delivering her own rendition of Amerie’s 2005 classic.
However, it was her cover of ‘1 Thing’ that quickly got people talking, with clips of the performance circulating across social media and dividing listeners.
Some viewers were left unimpressed by Willow’s vocal delivery, with critics questioning her pitch, singing style and expressive facial movements throughout the performance. Others also questioned whether the track was the right song choice, given Amerie’s distinctive vocals and the song’s demanding rhythm.
One social media user joked that Willow sounded like she was “singing through mosquito attacks”, while another suggested her voice was better suited to artists such as Alanis Morissette or Sarah McLachlan.
However, not everyone was against the performance, with some fans coming to Willow’s defence and praising her for singing live without relying on noticeable backing vocals or autotune.
Others argued that ‘1 Thing’ is a particularly challenging song to perform, pointing out that its fast-paced, percussion-heavy production makes it difficult to recreate the energy of the original.
Originally released in 2005, Amerie’s ‘1 Thing’ became one of the defining R&B hits of the 2000s, earning widespread recognition for its infectious beat and instantly recognisable chorus.

Willow, who first rose to fame with her 2010 hit ‘Whip My Hair’, has since carved out a musical identity of her own, experimenting with alternative rock, R&B and more experimental sounds.
The viral performance has once again placed the singer at the centre of online conversation, with listeners continuing to debate whether her interpretation was an interesting reinvention or a miss.